Siding

Service overview

We know that choosing a siding contractor can be a bit uneasy. That’s why we offer free inspections. During the complimentary inspection we will provide a variety of siding options, give industry insights, and address any questions. We don’t start the project until we know exactly what our customer needs and we make sure they get the quality service they deserve. Marvel Contracting stresses customer satisfaction, quality, and reliability as the key values of the company and we do our best to uphold them.

We offer:

  • Certified, insured & bonded contractor
  • A variety of siding choices: Vinyl, Cedar, LP Smartside, James Hardie and more
  • 15 years of service with a long list of happy customers
  • 50-year protection warranty for GAF shingles
  • Over 1000 successful projects and counting
  • 10-year labor warranty
  • Top-quality craftsmanship

We do:

  • Vinyl siding
  • Cement board siding

Get a free estimate

Tell us about your project and we will get back to you. You can also call us at 347-514-6785.

Siding for New York homes

Siding is the part of your house that takes every storm, every August afternoon and every January freeze, and mostly it does it without complaint. When it finally does complain, the signs are easy to miss until water has already found its way behind the panels. This page covers what we look at when a New York homeowner asks about new siding, with most of the focus on vinyl because it is what most of our siding conversations end up being about.

We work across New York City, Nassau County and Suffolk County, and the houses here vary a lot. A brick-and-frame two-family in Queens has different needs than a ranch in Suffolk a few blocks from the bay. Keep that in mind as you read, because the right answer is rarely the same twice.

Why vinyl is so common

Vinyl is colored all the way through, so a scratch does not show bare primer the way a scraped painted board does. It never needs repainting, and a yearly rinse with a hose and a soft brush handles most of the upkeep. For a lot of households that low-effort routine is the whole appeal.

It is also forgiving on budget compared with the alternatives, and the range of colors and profiles is wide. The trade-off is that vinyl is thin and flexible. Strong heat can warp it, hard impacts can crack it, and it will never have the look of a hand-finished wood wall. Knowing those limits up front makes it much easier to pick well.

Wood-look and shake-look profiles

Not all vinyl looks like vinyl anymore. Some lines are embossed with a wood-grain texture, and others are molded into thick cedar-shake or scalloped shingle shapes. Used on a gable, a dormer or a front-facing bay, they add visual interest without the repainting that real cedar demands.

Our usual advice is to use a profile like this as an accent rather than on every wall. A whole house of shake panels can look heavy, while a field of horizontal clapboard with shake in the gables tends to look right on a Cape or a colonial. If you are matching a neighbor’s older siding, bring us a sample, because grain patterns and sheen differ between manufacturers.

How vinyl compares with fiber cement, aluminum and wood

Each material earns its place on certain houses. Here is how we think about them.

  • Fiber cement is heavier, harder to cut and slower to install, and it needs specialized tools and careful handling. In return it resists moisture, rot and pests, does not burn, and has a more substantial look. It needs repainting roughly every decade or so and periodic recaulking at seams and trim.
  • Aluminum resists fire, insects and rot and can be repainted, but it dents easily, which matters on a house with kids, bikes and a lawn mower.
  • Wood is beautiful, and cedar holds up better against rot and insects than pine. It also asks for the most work: yearly inspection and refinishing every several years.
  • Vinyl asks for the least upkeep and usually costs the least up front, with the limits on looks and extreme heat that we covered above.

Fiber cement generally costs more to buy and to install, so the choice often comes down to whether you want to pay more now for a longer-lived, more upscale wall, or less now for easy care. Neither answer is wrong. For a ballpark on your own house, try the cost estimator instead of relying on national averages, which tend to miss how local labor and access actually work out.

Choosing a vinyl product

When you compare samples, three things matter more than the color card.

Thickness and profile

Panels run from about 0.040 inches at the thin end up to roughly 0.045 inches in premium lines. Flex a sample in your hands. A stiffer panel with a deep profile and a doubled nailing hem lies flatter on the wall and resists waves. Thickness is only part of the story, though. The formulation of the vinyl itself has a lot to do with how well it handles impact.

Warranty

Many quality lines carry long or lifetime warranties, but the words on the box do not tell you much. Read the document. Does it cover fading and chalking? Does it transfer if you sell the house? Does the coverage shrink over time? Ask us to go through the fine print with you before you commit, and keep a copy with your house papers.

Wind rating

Manufacturers publish a design wind speed for their panels, and it varies by product line. That number matters on exposed lots, and we compare it against what your location is likely to see. Nothing replaces proper fastening, but a better-rated panel with a good locking profile gives you more margin.

Dark colors deserve a second look too. They absorb more heat, which is hard on vinyl, so many manufacturers limit or warrant them differently. Lighter and mid-tone colors also hide dirt and fade less obviously.

What a good installation involves

Most vinyl failures we get called to fix come down to how it went on, not what it was made of. Vinyl expands and contracts with the temperature, and the installation has to let it. The sequence goes roughly like this.

  1. Strip or repair whatever is there. The wall has to be clean, dry and flat. Rot, loose sheathing and failed flashing get fixed before anything new goes up.
  2. Cover the sheathing with house wrap or another weather barrier, lapped so water runs out and not in, and sealed around windows and doors.
  3. Install the trim and starter strip: corner posts, J-channel around openings, and a level starter course. A crooked first course shows in every row above it.
  4. Hang the panels and nail them loosely. Nails go in the center of the slots and stop about 1/32 inch short of the panel, so the panel can slide. Nailing tight is the classic cause of buckling.
  5. Leave expansion gaps where panels meet trim or stops, about 1/4 inch in normal weather and closer to 3/8 inch when it is below freezing. A 12-foot panel can grow by more than half an inch from cold to hot, which is why that space matters.
  6. Finish with the top courses and any soffit or fascia work, then walk the house and check that every panel is locked and none is pulled tight.

Window and door trim is where careless jobs show. The trim needs to be built so the siding can slide into it, and so water drains out. If you see siding pushed hard against casing with no room to move, that is a future problem.

Signs it is time to replace

One cracked panel is a repair. A pattern is a replacement conversation. Here is what pushes us toward recommending new siding.

  • Cracking, warping or sagging across large areas, not just in one spot
  • Fading that cleaning does not improve
  • Moisture behind the panels, such as soft sheathing, mold or stains on interior walls near exterior ones
  • Repairs that keep coming back, or replacement panels that no longer match because the color has been discontinued
  • Loose panels that rattle in a wind

Quality vinyl commonly lasts somewhere between 20 and 40 years with decent care, so a house with siding from the 1990s is in the window. Walk around it on a sunny day and look along the wall at a low angle. Waves and gaps show up much more clearly that way.

Keeping it in good shape

Maintenance is light, but it is not zero. Once a year, rinse off dust and cobwebs with a hose, then scrub any stubborn spots with a soft brush and mild soap. A cleaner made for vinyl handles tough stains. Skip abrasive powders and harsh solvents, which can dull the surface.

While you are out there, look for loose or cracked panels and fix them quickly, because small gaps let water in. Cut back shrubs and low branches that rub the wall. A repair is easiest when you have a spare piece, and a piece taken from a hidden spot, like behind the meter or under a deck, matches faded siding better than a brand-new one.

If you find moisture or rot behind a panel, that is not a cosmetic job anymore. It often leads back to the roof edge, a gutter or a window, which is why we sometimes pair siding work with roofing repairs.

Long Island wind, salt and freeze-thaw

Near the water in Nassau and Suffolk, siding deals with gusts, blowing sand and salt air. Panels with a high wind rating and good fastening are worth the attention here, and so are stainless or corrosion-resistant fasteners and flashing in the most exposed spots. Rinsing salt film off the wall once or twice a year helps too.

Further inland and in the city, the issue is more often the swing in temperature. Winters that go below freezing make vinyl stiffer and a little more brittle, which is another reason installers should leave the right gap in cold weather and be careful not to strike panels with a hammer. Fiber cement is sometimes preferred for severe exposure, so if your house sits right at the shoreline, we are happy to talk through both options.

Older homes and historic neighborhoods

A lot of housing in the five boroughs and on the older Long Island villages is decades or even a century old. Putting vinyl over original wood clapboards can hide problems and change the depth of window and door trim. Sometimes the better move is to remove the old siding, see what is underneath and repair it.

If your home sits in a designated historic district or is a landmark, there may be rules on materials and appearance. In New York City that can mean approval from the Landmarks Preservation Commission, and some Long Island villages have their own review boards. Check before you buy anything. We can help you work out what to ask, and if you are thinking about a bigger exterior change, our architectural design service is a good place to start. Brick and stone walls have their own needs, and our masonry team can speak to those.

Permits and getting a quote

Whether you need a permit for a siding replacement depends on where you live and how much work is involved. NYC jobs fall under the Department of Buildings, and towns and villages on Long Island each have their own building department, so check with yours. We can talk it through with you when you reach out.

The easiest first step is to ask for a free estimate. We will look at the walls, the existing condition and what you want the house to look like, and tell you what we see.

Siding questions we hear a lot

How long does vinyl siding last?

Quality vinyl commonly lasts between 20 and 40 years. Exposure, color, installation and upkeep all change that.

Can new siding go over the old?

Sometimes, but we prefer to look at what is underneath first. Hidden rot and failed flashing are hard to judge from the outside, and covering them up just delays the cost.

Does vinyl need painting?

No. The color runs through the panel. Painting vinyl is generally discouraged, and dark paint in particular can cause heat problems.

Why does my siding look wavy?

Usually it was nailed too tight, so it cannot move when it warms up. Heat reflected from a nearby window, such as a low-E glass unit, can also distort panels.

How much will it cost?

It depends on the size of the house, the product and how much repair the walls need. Use the cost estimator for a starting range, then we can refine it at a visit.

Further reading from This Old House

© Copyright 2026 Marvel Contracting